Low-carb and keto diets: Criticism outpaces evidence

July 18 2019 by in Keto, Low carb & high fat

Anyone who follows a keto lifestyle is no stranger to hearing how terrible it is from uninformed and unqualified pundits on social media.

A recent editorial in JAMA Internal Medicine, however, is written by experienced, respected physicians, and it calls into question the evidence supporting the “hype” of keto diets. These authors certainly are not unqualified, and they are not uninformed, at least not in other areas of nutrition science.

JAMA Internal Medicine: The ketogenic diet for obesity and diabetes — enthusiasm outpaces evidence

The authors do, however, reveal some clear biases. While I applaud their efforts to focus on evidence, I am afraid they missed the mark.

I will address many of their points in this post, but for a deeper discussion of the science backing keto, I encourage you to read our guide “The science of low carb and keto.” It contains dozens of links to studies supporting the use of low-carb and keto diets for weight loss, diabetes, liver disease, PCOS and more.

Getting back to the JAMA editorial, a crucial point that we cannot ignore is that the authors are known vegan advocates and have commercial interests in promoting a vegan diet; all three are associated with the vegan promotional film “Forks Over Knives.” While that does not invalidate the evidence they cite, it may explain why — out of the vast literature on low-carb diets — they chose the evidence they did. Their dietary biases likely cloud their judgement and unfortunately keep them from seeing the broader picture. This is clear right away from their language.

For instance, they refer to the keto diet as requiring followers to “forgo nearly all carbohydrates.” I would have phrased this as allowing followers to “eat almost endless amounts of above-ground veggies as their source of real-food, natural carbohydrates.”

It turns out the words we use matter, as do our conflicts of interest.

But what about the science? For starters, they fall back on the mantra that all we need to do to lose weight is restrict calories. How can we blame obesity and metabolic disease on a low-fat diet when statistics show we eat more calories than we used to?

This type of thinking completely ignores the human aspect of food and weight loss. Following a diet that we enjoy, that keeps us full, and reduces our cravings is the key to reducing caloric intake. We aren’t calorimeters. We are people with emotions, cravings and hunger.

It also ignores the fact that both the timing of our eating and the degree of insulin stimulation from carbohydrates contribute to weight loss (or lack thereof). Although overall calories do matter, they do not exist in a vacuum. The quality of those calories matters just as much, if not more than quantity.

Next, the authors refer to a 2013 meta analysis of randomized controlled trials (regarded as the highest level of evidence) that shows low-carb diets lead to greater weight loss than low-fat diets. However, they question the significance of the 1 kilogram weight difference. That is fair, as 1 kilogram is not much. But they neglect to mention that the low-carb group also had significantly better blood pressure, triglycerides and HDL (also shown in this 2016 meta-analysis). That would certainly suggest that either the weight loss difference was clinically significant or that there were additional benefits to low-carb diet beyond weight loss. Those are important conclusions from the study that an unbiased assessment would not have overlooked!

This next part surprised me. The authors suggested that there is no quality evidence to support low-carb or keto diets for diabetes. I guess the American Diabetes Association disagrees as it recently amended its recommendations to include low-carb and keto diets as an evidence-based treatment option to control blood glucose and diabetes.

The authors also called into question the Virta Health data showing improvement and even remission of type 2 diabetes with keto diets out to two years. They are correct when they pointed out that this trial was not randomized and included interacting with a health coach via a smart phone app.

Regardless, we cannot ignore the fact that the Virta trial showed better remission rates and medication elimination rates than any dietary study in the medical literature. While the keto group may have received more support, based on this study, there is no debating that keto eating was part of the most impressive diabetes reversal program in the medical literature. For the sake of millions of patients struggling to manage type 2 diabetes, this point needs emphasis.

I am particularly interested in the statement claiming it is more important to control glycemic levels while consuming “healthful carbohydrate rich foods…even in the absence of weight loss.” In an editorial promoting the importance of evidence, this statement curiously lacks a reference and sounds quite far-fetched to me.

There are plenty of other issues as well. The authors pointed to keto diets in kids that have led to nutrient deficiencies and rare complications. Most of these diets were made up of shakes and meal replacements rather than food, and therefore do not apply to modern-day, real-food keto diets.

In addition, they mention a laundry list of “complications” that are either short term (muscle cramps), mild (constipation), or simply not true (bone fractures and “multiple vitamin and mineral deficiencies”).

See our guide to low-carb and keto controversies here.

But perhaps the most glaring concern with this editorial is the statement that keto diets come at an “opportunity cost” of avoiding “healthy” whole grains, fruits and legumes. Once again, we need to look at the data more carefully and not get enticed by the headlines.

The majority of the trials showing benefit to whole grains compared them to refined grains. It shouldn’t be a surprise that whole grains are better than the refined grains found in processed food. Yet in the editorial, the authors imply that eating whole grains is healthier than eating a real-food, low-carb diet without grains. That is not an evidence-based claim, as that study has never been done.

The other set of data in support of whole grains, fruits and legumes comes from uncontrolled observational studies. For insulin-sensitive individuals with other healthy habits, such as those in “Blue Zones,” these foods can be part of an overall healthy lifestyle. It doesn’t mean they are the main cause of good health, it simply says they can be part of that lifestyle.

All we need to see is the glucose spikes from a patient with diabetes who eats “healthy” whole grains and fruits to know that these foods affect different people in different ways. Opportunity cost? I am more concerned with the opportunity cost of people missing the powerful tool of low carb because they think they need fruits and whole grains to be healthy. That is simply not true.

(See our full guide on whole grains here.)

In the end, while this is a thoughtful rebuttal against a keto diet, it still presents evidence from an overly biased perspective and fails to see the whole picture. Low-carb and keto diets are absolutely supported by the literature to help with weight loss and the reversal of type 2 diabetes.

That’s my bias. I strive every day to acknowledge it and present information as objectively as I can. That’s why I encourage everyone to read our science of low carb and keto guide with extensive references to support the health benefits of low-carb living. Low-carb and keto diets are a powerful tool for health, and we have to see past the biases that some experts bring to a review of the literature in order to help our patients and help ourselves.

Thanks for reading,
Bret Scher MD FACC

Low carb and keto science

GuideA summary of the core scientific evidence behind low-carb and keto diets. While these diets are still somewhat controversial, there is now high-quality evidence.

Earlier

American Diabetes Association endorses low-carb diet as option

NuSI study raises potential concerns about a keto diet

Keto

MEMBERS ONLY
All things keto with Keto Connect
16:44
What is it like running the very popular YouTube channel Keto Connect?
MEMBERS ONLY
My success story with Jim Caldwell
02:23
Jim Caldwell has transformed his health and gone from an all-time high at 352 lbs (160 kg) to 170 lbs (77 kg.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Diet Doctor Podcast #35 with Ben Bikman, PhD
00:00
Why is insulin so important for us to control and why does a ketogenic diet help so many people? Professor Ben Bikman has studied these questions in his lab for years and he is one of the foremost authorities on the subject.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
Diet Doctor Podcast #31 – Dr. Ken Berry
51:26
Dr. Ken Berry wants us all to be aware that much of what our doctors say may be a lie. Maybe not an outright malicious lie, but much of what “we” believe in medicine can be traced back to word-of-mouth teachings without a scientific basis.
MEMBERS ONLY
My success story with Gillian Szollos
02:55
Gillian had a normal life when she all of a sudden started to get seizures. She suffered terrible side effects from the meds so she started a keto diet.
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY
MEMBERS ONLY

Name

Provider / Domain

Expiration

Description

ckdc-premium

.dietdoctor.com

1 month

app-banner

.dietdoctor.dev.dietdoctor.com

1 day

This cookie shows whether user closed the App Banner prompt

_gaexp

Google LLC

dietdoctor.com

1 year

Used to determine a user's inclusion in an experiment and the expiry of experiments a user has been included in.

_gaexp

Google LLC

.dietdoctor.com

1 year

Used to determine a user's inclusion in an experiment and the expiry of experiments a user has been included in.

_opt_awcid

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_opt_awmid

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_opt_awgid

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_opt_awkid

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_opt_utmc

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_opt_expid

.dietdoctor.com

25 seconds

gtm_auth

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

gtm_debug

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

gtm_experiment

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

gtm_preview

.dietdoctor.com

3 days

_hjAbsoluteSessionInProgress

Hotjar Ltd

.dietdoctor.com

30 minutes

The cookie is set so Hotjar can track the beginning of the user's journey for a total session count. It does not contain any identifiable information.

_ga

Google LLC

.dietdoctor.com

2 years

This cookie name is associated with Google Universal Analytics - which is a significant update to Google's more commonly used analytics service. This cookie is used to distinguish unique users by assigning a randomly generated number as a client identifier. It is included in each page request in a site and used to calculate visitor, session and campaign data for the sites analytics reports.

_dc_gtm_UA-3268327-1

.dietdoctor.com

1 minute

This cookie is associated with sites using Google Tag Manager to load other scripts and code into a page. Where it is used it may be regarded as Strictly Necessary as without it, other scripts may not function correctly. The end of the name is a unique number which is also an identifier for an associated Google Analytics account.

_hjFirstSeen

Hotjar Ltd

.dietdoctor.com

30 minutes

The cookie is set so Hotjar can track the beginning of the user's journey for a total session count. It does not contain any identifiable information.

_dc_gtm_UA-22012422-2

.dietdoctor.com

1 minute

AWSELBCORS

Amazon.com Inc.

www.podbean.com

5 minutes

The cookies AWSELB and AWSELBCORS are functionally the same cookies. The latter has an explicit SameSite attribute set because of changes made from Chrome 80 and upwards.

_ga_YMCP8KW9S4

.dietdoctor.com

2 years

_hjIncludedInSessionSample

Hotjar Ltd

www.dietdoctor.com

2 minutes

This cookie is set to let Hotjar know whether that visitor is included in the data sampling defined by your site's daily session limit

__cf_bm

Cloudflare Inc.

.vimeo.com

30 minutes

This cookie is used to distinguish between humans and bots. This is beneficial for the website, in order to make valid reports on the use of their website.

_gid

Google LLC

.dietdoctor.com

1 day

This cookie is set by Google Analytics. It stores and update a unique value for each page visited and is used to count and track pageviews.

CookieScriptConsent

CookieScript

www.dietdoctor.com

1 year

This cookie is used by Cookie-Script.com service to remember visitor cookie consent preferences. It is necessary for Cookie-Script.com cookie banner to work properly.

__cf_bm

Cloudflare Inc.

.podbean.com

30 minutes

This cookie is used to distinguish between humans and bots. This is beneficial for the website, in order to make valid reports on the use of their website.

_hjIncludedInPageviewSample

Hotjar Ltd

www.dietdoctor.com

2 minutes

This cookie is set to let Hotjar know whether that visitor is included in the data sampling defined by your site's pageview limit.

_dc_gtm_UA-22012422-1

.dietdoctor.com

1 minute

_gaexp_rc

.dietdoctor.com

25 seconds

Name

Provider / Domain

Expiration

Description

IDE

Google LLC

.doubleclick.net

1 year

This cookie is set by Doubleclick and carries out information about how the end user uses the website and any advertising that the end user may have seen before visiting the said website.

_uetvid

Microsoft Corporation

.dietdoctor.com

1 year

This is a cookie utilised by Microsoft Bing Ads and is a tracking cookie. It allows us to engage with a user that has previously visited our website.

loc

Oracle Corporation

.addthis.com

1 year 1 month

Stores the visitors geolocation to record location of sharer

test_cookie

Google LLC

.doubleclick.net

15 minutes

This cookie is set by DoubleClick (which is owned by Google) to determine if the website visitor's browser supports cookies.

_gcl_au

Google LLC

.dietdoctor.com

3 months

Used by Google AdSense for experimenting with advertisement efficiency across websites using their services

_uetsid

Microsoft Corporation

.dietdoctor.com

1 day

This cookie is used by Bing to determine what ads should be shown that may be relevant to the end user perusing the site.

uvc

Oracle Corporation

.addthis.com

1 year 1 month

Tracks how often a user interacts with AddThis

YSC

Google LLC

.youtube.com

Session

This cookie is set by YouTube to track views of embedded videos.

MUID

Microsoft Corporation

.bing.com

1 year

This cookie is widely used my Microsoft as a unique user identifier. It can be set by embedded microsoft scripts. Widely believed to sync across many different Microsoft domains, allowing user tracking.

_fbp

Meta Platform Inc.

.dietdoctor.com

3 months

Used by Facebook to deliver a series of advertisement products such as real time bidding from third party advertisers

VISITOR_INFO1_LIVE

Google LLC

.youtube.com

6 months

This cookie is set by Youtube to keep track of user preferences for Youtube videos embedded in sites;it can also determine whether the website visitor is using the new or old version of the Youtube interface.

Name

Provider / Domain

Expiration

Description

_ga_7S1SXKKDKN

.dietdoctor.com

2 years

Name

Provider / Domain

Expiration

Description

_hjSession_1945121

.dietdoctor.com

30 minutes

_hjSessionUser_1945121

.dietdoctor.com

1 year

_ga_Y4DLH4EPXM

.dietdoctor.com

2 years