Why a tax on red meat is a bad idea
Last week, we saw headlines suggesting that a global meat tax could save hundreds of thousands of lives and billions of health-care dollars annually.
CNBC: Health experts propose a red meat tax to recoup $172 billion in health care-costs
BBC: Should there be a tax on red meat?
The headlines all stem, not from global policymakers’ serious consideration of such a tax, but rather, from a single modeling study out of the University of Oxford, published last week in PLOS. A modeling study is more “academic exercise” than rigorous science.
Of course, the whole notion that red meat contributes to increased rates of chronic disease is based on weak epidemiological evidence, a type of evidence that needs to be tested in randomized clinical trials to establish causation. These trials have never been conducted. So, in spite of the compelling headlines that this modeling study generated, the whole premise on which it is based (that red and/or processed meat consumption increases rates of chronic disease) is tenuous at best.
Moreover, beyond the fact that the entire premise for a meat tax may be false, there are a couple of other realities about a meat tax that are particularly grating. Nutritionists broadly agree that meat is a nutrient dense, protein-packed food, and adequate protein is important for health. If a use tax reduces meat consumption, there is no guarantee that people will replace the lost meat calories with foods like broccoli and lentils, which are presumed to be healthier; it is just as likely (or perhaps more likely) that nutritionally depleted (but tasty) processed foods made with refined carbohydrates and vegetable oils would be the replacement of choice. That switch would diminish health, not improve it.
In addition, this sort of tax is regressive, which means it would hit poor and malnourished populations harder than more affluent groups. A big jump in the cost of meat is likely to push budget-conscious shoppers towards inexpensive and highly processed calories. This would be anything but helpful for those who are already struggling to make ends meet (pun intended).
For a longer look at the issue of a meat tax, consider the following post by Diana Rodgers, RD:
Sustainable Dish: Is a meat tax a good idea?
Earlier
Cardiologist in Houston Chronicle: ‘Want a healthier heart? Eat a steak’
What about red meat and health?
‘What the Health’ review: health claims backed by no solid evidence
Guides
Protein on a low-carb or keto diet
Dietary guidelines
![Did the introduction of the dietary guidelines start the obesity epidemic?]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Tim Noakes on trial]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![The human body needs good saturated fats — Dr. Ken Berry]()
![The US dietary guidelines: why they matter]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
!["Dietary guidelines for whom?"]()
![The unknown story of vegetable oils]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![How to prevent chronic disease – Dr. Trudi Deakin]()
![Creating change in public health]()
![A global food revolution]()
![A low-carb diet for T2D reversal – Dr. Sarah Hallberg]()
![Diet Doctor Podcast #30 – Dr. Gary Fettke]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Why our dietary guidelines are wrong]()
![Q&A with Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![The three top most common myths about low carb]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Helping people learn low carb in Brazil]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![LCHF – who benefits financially?]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![What about red meat and health?]()
![Diet Doctor podcast #15 with Prof. Andrew Mente]()
Low carb
- MEMBERS ONLY
!["I sort of wanted to save the world"]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Q&A with Franziska Spritzler]()
![Low-carb tips with team Diet Doctor – Traveling]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Why a low-carb diet and other questions]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
!["A more pleasurable way to live"]()
![A global food revolution]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Low-carb living]()
![7 tips to make low carb simple]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![How to formulate a low-carb keto diet]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Living low carb with Caroline Smale]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Everything in moderation?]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![The cause of obesity]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![The latest science behind a keto diet]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Are there potential dangers with a low-carb diet?]()
![Women's questions introduction]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![The three top most common myths about low carb]()
- MEMBERS ONLY
![Low carb explained]()
![Q&A with Dr. Andreas Eenfeldt]()
